Vacca, J. L., Vacca, R.T., & Gove, M K. (2012). Reading and learning to read (8th ed.). New York: Longman.
Textbooks rely on expository style of wringing: Description, classification, and explanation. They are dry and less appealing for students. ELL find complex content nd new vocabulary daunting.
Why are content area text books difficult? Assumptions about vocabulary, prior knowledge, and readability of content areas.
Factors judging difficulty:
- Difficulty if text- look at source of information:
- primary publisher descriptions, design format organizational structure, grade-level readability designations.
- Your knowledge of students in the class.
- Your own sense of what makes the text useful for learning a subject.
Comprehension depends on background knowledge and logical organization of expository text. Content text books linguistic characteristics are technical abstract, dense, and authoritative in nature. Their sentence structure can be complex and long or short and choppy. The length of reading assignments is another factor in terms of readability or ELL. ELL may have adequate conversation skills but lack academic English vocabulary. Suggestions for ELL:
- As content area text readings are introduced, check ELL learners understanding of key terms
- Consider having ELLs read summaries or shorter subsections text rather than lengthy reading assignments
- Decide whether examples in text will clarify understanding or will create an overload of information
- Supply students with an outline of text prior to reading
- Consider relevance of material to ELL background information
2. Usability: is it considerate and user friendly? Does the table of contents provide good overview? Do subheadings clearly break out the important concepts of the chapter? Are terms in bold or italics?
3. How interesting is the text? Text should appeal to students. Is the writing style appealing to students? Does the book clearly show the knowledge being learned might be used by reader in the future?
Readability: Readability formulas help estimate the textbook difficulty. They typically involve a measure of sentence length and word difficulty to ascertain a grade-level score for text material. The score generally indicates the reading achievement level students would need to comprehend the material. Limitation: This is only an estimate. It does not account for background knowledge, interest, motivation, culture or ability. Teachers can use the Fry readability Graph to measure readability. The graph takes into account number of syllables per 100 words and number of sentences per 100 words. Teachers may decide to use leveled trade books to match students with appropriate reading material based on reading achievement as well. These books consider numbers of words on a page, type size, layout, and how illustrations support the text.
Organizing textbook readings: Use cooperative learning groups/literature circles to teach from a textbook
- Textmaster roles:
- Discussion director- creates questions for group based on personal reactions and concerns about main ideas of a text that is read.
- Summarizer- Shares a synthesis of key points.
- Vocabulary enricher- Jots down key words and defines puzzling words
- Webmaster- Creates graphic organizer that visually displays main ideas including vocabulary and examples.
Idea sketches: Graphic organizers that students complete in small groups as they read from textbook material. The students focus on main ideas and supporting details.
Trade books: Trade books can provide more enriching reading experience than textbooks, capturing children’s interest and imagination in people, places, events, and ideas. Teachers should weave trade books in content rea learning so that the instructional activities are relevant.
Literature across the curriculum: Using trade books in tandem with textbooks or in units of study around thematic unit. It can provide students with intense involvement in subject and are powerful schema builders. They can also accommodate a range of abilities and backgrounds.
Schema: Intense involvement in a subject generates background knowledge the makes textbook concepts easier to grasp and assimilate. Reading both nonfiction and fiction books about the same topic helps build background knowledge and prepares and motivates them to read a variety of genres.
Literature web: Falls under single-discipline model in which a theme identified as important for the grade level is the base on standards identified. Either a single narrative or multiple text (text sets) are selected as a primary source of information. The literature web shows students different books related to a theme and categorized into other subtopics.
Narrative informational texts: The author tells a fictional story that conveys factual information.
Expository informational books: Text that does not contain stories. They contain information that follows specific text structure such as: description, sequence, cause and effect, comparison and contrast and problem solving. They often have a table of contents, a glossary, a list of illustrations, charts, and graphs. They don’t have to be read in any particular order.
Mixed-text informational books: Narrate stories and include factual information in the surrounding text. Example: the magic school bus is a fictional story but has factual information in it.
Strategies before reading: Previewing and skimming help students get a general understanding, how to size up material, judge its relevance to a topic or gain a good idea of what passage is about.
- Previewing: Should help students become aware of the purpose of reading assignment. What kind of reading will they be doing? What is the goal? How much time will the assignment take? These questions prepare students for what is coming.
- Valuable clues about overall structure of a book or the ideas in a chapter: Point out table of contents (shows theme or structure, can be used to build background knowledge), preface, chapter introduction or summaries, and chapter questions.
- Skimming: This is a natural part of previewing to see what the assignment will be about. Have students read the first sentence of every paragraph (usually the important idea). Have students skim a section of their book in 1-2 minutes and provide a summary to the class.
Organizer: Provides a frame of reference for comprehending text precisely to help readers make connections between prior knowledge and new material. they can be written previews or verbal presentations. There will be highlighted concepts and also explicit links to background knowledge and reading. Guidelines for an organizer: analyze content, identify main ideas, link ideas to students experience, raise questions that will interest students in thinking about the text being read.
Graphic organizer: Ideas are arranged to show relationships to each other. Graphic organizers can help students understand key concepts about subject matter, organize main ideas, and vocabulary.
Anticipation guides: An activity to help build anticipation for reading in which the teacher asks for oral or written statements before reading a text. Students rely on what they already know to make educated guesses about material to be read. They also make predictions. Guidelines for Anticipating Guides: analyze material, determine ideas where students will interact with, write ideas in declarative statements, out statements into a format that twill elicit anticipation and prediction making, discuss readers predictions prior to reading, assign reading, contrast readers predictions with authors intended meaning.
Point-of-view guides: Questions presented in an interview format. Students role play, writing in the first person to ensure that different perspectives are being taken. Students contribute their experiences to the role which enhances recall and comprehension.
Idea circles: Small peer-led group discussions of concepts fueled by multiple text sources. They are like literature circles because they are composed fo 3-6 students. Students discuss concepts. They read different books and bring information to the table. They discuss facts and relationships.
Curriculum-based reader’s theater: Develop scripts that are based on curriculum content. Students read sections of text, work in small groups, and rewrite the main ideas in the form of an entertaining script. Increases fluency, enhances understanding of content, and motivates to read.
I-charts: Created to organize note taking, encourage critical thinking that builds on students prior knowledge and increase metacognitive awareness. Students identify what they want to know, organize the information read, and determine if they adequately answered their questions.
Internet inquiry: Use the internet for learning about contain areas, understand organizational patterns of websites because they differ from text. Teachers must make sure students are able to use information technology to actively learn. Teachers should plan and organize internet inquiry. Carefully orchestrated activities result in creative high-level creative thinking skills.
Webquest: A model that features systematic searching and focuses on supporting students’ learning through synthesis and evaluation and analysis. It involves an introduction intended to motivate students, a task that describes the final project, steps that students take to accomplish final product, list of web-base resources, a rubric for student evaluation, and a conclusion that focuses on reflection and discussion.
Classroom Application
Use literature circles to help teach content text:
- Textmaster roles:
- Discussion director- creates questions for group based on personal reactions and concerns about main ideas of a text that is read.
- Summarizer- Shares a synthesis of key points.
- Vocabulary enricher- Jots down key words and defines puzzling words
- Webmaster- Creates graphic organizer that visually displays main ideas including vocabulary and examples.
Use strategies for text previewing:

Make use of Point-of-view guides: Questions presented in an interview format. Students role play, writing in the first person to ensure that different perspectives are being taken. Students contribute their experiences to the role which enhances recall and comprehension.
Review and reflect on using Webquest as a tool for internet inquiry in the classroom.
Use Bill Chapman’s Classroom Tools (www.classroomtools.com) to help students validate online information. Also reference this location for motivational easy to engage students in learning.





















